Guides / AU procurement / Debriefs

Debriefs

A debrief is instruments, not a rerun of the fight.


Under Australian procurement regulations, unsuccessful tenderers are entitled to a formal post-award debrief to understand how their submission scored against the published criteria. Use debrief feedback to refine your future qualification filters rather than relitigating completed decisions. Part of our guide on Australian government procurement; see also probity and feedback boundaries.

Published: 2 September 2026 · By Bill · Reviewed by Andre · selrob

Takeaways

  • Ask in writing. Take someone who will not defend the last draft.
  • You get how you were scored against the published criteria, not a rerun.
  • If the weights sat outside what you do, that is a strategy fail you should have seen in week one.
  • A firm that never asks is flying without instruments.

What are you entitled to after a loss?

On most public processes, a debrief. A structured account of how you were scored against the published criteria, and where you were weak. Not a rerun of the evaluation. Not the competitor’s price. Not a chance to lodge extra material. Follow the process in the pack. Ask in writing. Do it while the evaluation is still in someone’s head.

Private buyers may offer nothing. Ask anyway, once, without a lecture. Silence is information. So is a vague paragraph that could have been a template.

How do you use it?

To test the next bid/no-bid. If a mandatory was missed, that is a process fail on the first hunt. If the weights sat outside what you do, that is a strategy fail you should have seen in week one. If the incumbent’s evidence library was always going to win, the next pack from the same buyer deserves a colder read. See wired for the incumbent.

Write one sentence on the gate: we will not bid this category until X is true. If you cannot write that sentence, you had a meeting, not a debrief.

What should you not do?

Argue. Relitigate. Send the writer who is still angry. Ask for a score you can use to attack the process. Firms that treat every debrief as proof the evaluation was unfair are flying with the instruments covered. The useful output is a change to the next call, not a feeling about the last one.

Do not skip the debrief because you are already on the next inbound. The next inbound is why you go. Without instruments you will bid the same category the same way.

How does this feed win rate?

It does not, directly. It feeds the gate. Cost per win falls when you stop paying for the nos you already knew. A debrief that names a mandatory you missed is the cheapest lesson in the economics of bidding. A debrief you never asked for is a lesson you will buy again.

Where tenders are published is how the next one arrives. The debrief is how you decide whether to open it. AusTender and the state portals are the pointer. This page is the instrument after a loss.

Keep reading

Elsewhere in this guide.

Questions

Worth answering before you close the tab.

What is a tender debrief?

A structured account, after award, of how you were scored against the published criteria. Not a rerun, and not the competitor’s price.

Are you entitled to a debrief in Australia?

On most public processes, yes. Ask in writing, following the pack. Private buyers may offer nothing. Ask once anyway.

How should you use a debrief?

To write one sentence for the next gate: we will not bid this category until X is true. Not to relitigate the last draft.

Book a call

Bring the last tender you regretted.

In 30 minutes we’ll show you the call selrob would have made, and the working behind it.